I just got these boots in the mail today (and it was three days ahead of schedule!) I have had them on for around 9 hours (I went to work) and they have held up very good so far! The foot area fits very well, provided that I bought 1/2 size up like a lot of other reviews had said. I typically wear a 10 & 1/2 so I order an 11. They are pretty snug around my calves and are a tad hard to zip up all the way, but I have larger calves so this was expected. I hit the back of a step and there was a small scratch, but I could just easily lick my thumb and wipe it right off.
These boots are very fashionable also! They are my first pair of knee-high fashion boots and I love them already! I would question their long-lasting abilities but I would recommend them for someone who wants a seasonal and inexpensive pair of boots!