I am usually an 8 or 8.5 in shoes and boots. I'm 5'6" and weigh 115 pounds, so I have thin calves. The description says "runs a half size larger", what ever they mean by that. I debated maybe buying the 8, but I went instead for the 8.5, just to be safe. I'm very glad I did. They fit my feet EXACTLY, whereas other boots I've gotten from Amazon, in 8.5, fit a bit big. I compensate by adding a shoe pad, and wearing thick socks. I don't think I'll need a pad for these. They are VERY comfortable, and the heel is a great size. The lacing fits great. If you have more muscular calves, you can easily let the laces out.
Some reviews have said that they were unhappy, because the boots previously were matte and more weathered-looking. They complained that what they got now is a cheap, shiny patent leather. I studied that before I ordered. NOTE that the colors show Black, Brown, and Tan, followed by Black 15, Brown 15, Tan 15. I figured that the 15 refers to the newer model, hence the shiny kind. They're even more expensive. I went with the ones that did not say 15, and they are the weathered ones, definitely beautiful. Today, I received the Brown and the Tan, both gorgeous. Of course, from up close, they look like pleather, but from a distance, they look like really expensive leather boots. For the looks and the fit, the price is perfect.

I ordered this shoes with a little skepticism because I'm only used to order 'Prime' items, but I found these Riverberry 'Gaby' shoes and wanted to give it a shot. I have to say my feet are very picky in terms of shoes and finding something stylish and comfortable I can wear to work. I have bunions and flat feet, so that tells you everything. These shoes proved to be not only stylish but comfortable for my picky feet. I am very happy I ordered these shoes, they are beautiful and look more expensive than they are! Ordered another 2 pairs of a different style and I'm very pleased with this purchase. Will be ordering more colors in the future!